![]()
Photo: LPS.1, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million — about $887 million — after finding that the Facebook app for Android accessed users’ private photos and videos without their specific consent. The penalty, announced at the weekend, is the largest the Italian regulator has ever imposed, and amounts to about 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue.
The authority, known as the Garante, said the case affects around 20 million Android users in Italy, who were unaware that granting Facebook permission to access their photos also allowed the company to use them for additional purposes. Meta says it strongly disagrees with the decision and plans to appeal.
The feature at the centre of the case
The dispute centres on a Facebook feature introduced in 2023 called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook.” The feature suggests photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery that they might want to share in a post — a convenience that, in the regulator’s account, came with a hidden cost.
Facebook sought permission to access the gallery through a single request that applied across the whole app. The Garante found that the notice shown before that request failed to explain that granting access would also let Facebook use the contents of the gallery — photos, videos and their metadata — to suggest posts. Users, in other words, agreed to one thing and got another.
Italian law, implementing the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive, gives special protection to information stored on personal devices, including smartphones. It requires users to give free and informed consent before that information can be accessed — consent that must be specific, not bundled into a general permission.
How the case unfolded
The investigation began in July 2025, after a complaint from the Consumer Protection Centre of Bolzano, a city in northern Italy. The authority conducted a technical examination of the app’s permission system and concluded that Meta had breached Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code.
Alongside the fine, the Garante gave Meta 60 days to change how the feature works. The company must introduce a separate, explicit consent request explaining why Facebook needs access to users’ photo galleries, how the data will be used and how to turn the access off. The feature must be switched off by default in the meantime — including for users who have already granted permission.
Meta’s response — and what the case did not cover
Meta told the BBC it “strongly disagree[s] with the [regulator’s] assessment of the facts, its application of the law, and the disproportionate level of the fine,” and confirmed it would appeal. The company has also said the proceedings did not involve using personal content to train artificial intelligence models — a practice it denied.
The authority confirmed that the possible use of gallery content to train AI models was outside the scope of this investigation. It added that it had reserved the right to assess separately a newer feature, launched in 2026, that allows content from users’ galleries to be processed in the cloud.
Why it matters beyond Italy
The ruling is the latest in a long European campaign to force big technology companies to ask properly before taking personal data. Its logic — that consent must be specific, informed and separate for each purpose — applies well beyond one Facebook feature, and other regulators will be watching the appeal closely.
For users, the practical lesson is simpler: a permission granted to an app may cover more than it appears to. The Garante’s 60-day order is designed to make that bargain visible, one explicit question at a time.
What to watch next
- The appeal: whether Meta challenges the fine — and on what grounds.
- The 60-day deadline: how Meta redesigns the gallery feature for Italian users.
- The cloud feature: the Garante’s separate assessment of the 2026 gallery-processing tool.
- The wider pattern: whether other European regulators follow Italy’s lead on bundled permissions.
Sources: The Indian Express; Engadget; Ynet News; BBC via Globe News Bangkok.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your view.
Leave a comment