![]()
Photo: Jovianeye, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The US Supreme Court has refused to hear the Trump administration’s appeal in the fight over cancelled research grants at the University of California, leaving in place lower-court rulings that the cuts likely violated the First Amendment. The justices acted on Monday, November 16, in a one-line order with no explanation and no dissent noted, according to Reuters and SCOTUSblog.
The case, Trump v. Thakur, concerns grants from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities that were terminated in early 2025, after President Donald Trump signed executive orders targeting diversity, equity and inclusion programmes. The administration’s own petition put about $59 million in remaining grant funding at issue, with some awards running as late as November 2029.
For the researchers, the practical effect is immediate: the grants keep being paid while the case continues. For the administration, it is a setback in a much larger campaign — billions of dollars in other research grants remain tied up in separate litigation, CNN reported.
What the lower courts found
University of California researchers led by Neeta Thakur filed a class action in 2025 after federal agencies cut their grants under the January 2025 executive orders. US District Judge Rita Lin in San Francisco ordered the grants restored, finding the terminations likely punished researchers for their perceived viewpoints. On May 26, a panel of the Ninth US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that order for researchers whose grants were cut over diversity, equity and inclusion, Reuters reported.
The grants at issue support work on racial equity in science education, science teaching for Indigenous young people, and the health risks of wildfire smoke in communities of colour and low-income neighbourhoods, according to reporting on the case.
The scale of the wider cuts is far larger than the $59 million in this case. Between January and July of last year, the White House terminated more than $900 million in grants to UC researchers, including nearly $600 million at UCLA alone, the Lookout news site reported. Much of that money is the subject of separate court challenges.
What the Supreme Court did — and did not — decide
It is important to be precise about what happened on Monday. The Supreme Court denied a petition for certiorari — a request that the justices review a lower-court decision. A denial is not a ruling on the merits. It does not endorse every sentence of the Ninth Circuit’s opinion, and it sets no nationwide precedent.
What it does is leave the Ninth Circuit’s ruling standing, which means the preliminary injunction protecting the class of grants terminated over perceived diversity-related viewpoints remains in force. The class action now returns to Judge Lin’s court for a ruling on the merits of the First Amendment claim.
The Ninth Circuit separately rejected the preliminary-injunction theory for a broader class of researchers whose grants were ended with unexplained form letters; that separate challenge is still pending in the Court of Federal Claims.
Why the case matters beyond California
The dispute sits at the intersection of two big questions: how far a president can go in using the federal grant system to enforce an ideological agenda, and whether cutting already-awarded funding because of a researcher’s perceived viewpoint amounts to viewpoint discrimination under the First Amendment.
The lower courts sided, at least preliminarily, with the researchers — and the Supreme Court has now declined to disturb that. The decision will be watched closely by universities across the country, many of which have seen federal funding frozen or cancelled under the same orders.
What to watch next
- Tuesday’s hearing: lawyers for the UC researchers return to a lower court on Tuesday to argue that the administration’s termination of Department of Energy grants was also illegal, the Lookout reported.
- The merits trial: the Thakur class action continues in Judge Lin’s court, where the First Amendment claim will now be decided in full.
- The bigger litigation: billions of dollars in other grants remain in court, and a future case could still force the Supreme Court to rule on the merits.
- Congress and the agencies: whether the administration changes how it terminates grants in light of the rulings — or presses on with new cuts.
Sources: Reuters; CNN; SCOTUSblog; The Hill; Lookout Santa Cruz.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your view.
Leave a comment